Two National Tree flocked trees, Wintry Pine or Acacia Slim
National Tree Company makes both trees, Amazon.com sells both, and both carry the same warranty. The Wintry Pine is a medium pine with pine cones and red berries attached, the Acacia Slim a plain pencil tree that fits a corner, one band lower.
A decorated centerpiece or a plain corner tree
These two National Tree Company trees share a maker, a seller, a warranty and clear bulbs. They differ in shape and in what comes on the branches, so the choice comes from your floor plan and how much decorating you want to do.
Go with the National Tree Wintry Pine for a 47 in tree that looks dressed out of the box. Go with the National Tree Acacia Slim for a 26 in tree that slips into a corner and costs a band less.
On our best flocked Christmas trees page, the Wintry Pine is pick 6 and the Acacia Slim pick 4. The Wintry Pine meets our top pick in plain or decorated, and the Acacia Slim faces a full tree in slim or full.
The two National Tree trees side by side
All figures come from the Amazon listings and National Tree Company’s product details. Seller and warranty match, so those rows read the same.
| Feature | National Tree Wintry Pine | National Tree Acacia Slim |
|---|---|---|
| Height | 7.5 ft (90 in) | 7.5 ft, 88.5 in on the spec table |
| Width at the base | 47 in, medium profile | 26 in, pencil slim |
| Branch tips | 831 | 641 |
| Decorations | Pine cones and red berry clusters attached | None, snow flocking only |
| Lights | 650, pre-strung | 350, pre-strung |
| Light type | Clear incandescent; stay lit if one bulb goes out | Clear incandescent, UL listed; same stay-lit wiring |
| Modes | Steady, none listed | Steady, none listed |
| Stand | Metal base | Metal base |
| Weight | 33.2 lb | 13.4 lb |
| Warranty | 5-year tree, 2-year lights | 5 years tree, 2 years lights |
| Seller | Amazon.com | Amazon.com |
| Price band | $$$ | $$ |
47 in of medium pine or 26 in of pencil
The Wintry Pine spreads to 47 in at the base with 831 tips. The Acacia Slim holds 641 tips on a 26 in base, so it takes a little over half the width.
Wintry Pine owners are split on fullness, and some call it thinner than pictured. Acacia Slim owners praise how it fits small spaces and corners, and our guide to trees for small spaces explains how to give a narrow tree presence.
In a living room with space to walk around the tree, the Wintry Pine makes a centerpiece. In an entry, a dining nook or a bedroom, the Acacia Slim fits where the other would block the way.
Round goes to whichever width your floor allows.
Pine cones and berries or plain snow
Pine cones and red berry clusters come attached across the Wintry Pine’s branches. Owners call it gorgeous, and many homes need little beyond a topper and some ribbon to finish it.
The Acacia Slim is plain white flocking over green, with no attached decorations. That leaves the color scheme open, from all-white and silver to bright multicolor.
Our flocked tree decorating guide covers schemes for both, including how to work red and natural tones around fixed berries. Cream, gold and copper sit happily beside the red.
Round goes to the Wintry Pine for a finished look, to the Acacia Slim for freedom.
650 clear bulbs or 350
On both trees the clear incandescent bulbs keep shining when a single bulb fails, per the maker. The Wintry Pine has 650 of them and the Acacia Slim 350, roughly in step with their size.
Wintry Pine owners call the bulbs bright, though some report failures. Clear bulbs warm up as they run, so keep either tree 3 ft from heat sources, plug straight into a wall outlet, and switch off overnight.
Neither tree lists light modes, so expect a steady glow from both. If you want twinkle effects, that points away from these clear-bulb trees and toward an LED tree such as the Best Choice.
A draw, the same kind of light scaled to each tree.
45 to 60 minutes or about 30
Both trees have hinged branches. The maker allows 45 to 60 minutes for shaping the Wintry Pine and about 30 for the Acacia Slim, and owners of both call assembly easy.
The cones and berries make the Wintry Pine slower to fluff, since you shape around them. Expect some flocking on the floor with either, mostly in the first hour.
Gloves and an old sheet under the stand save cleanup. Working from the bottom section upward keeps the shape even as you go.
Round goes to the Acacia Slim, for the shorter setup.
33.2 lb or 13.4 lb to pack away
The Wintry Pine weighs 33.2 lb and the Acacia Slim 13.4 lb per their listings. The slim tree is the one you can carry alone, and its sections need far less closet space.
The Wintry Pine’s berries and cones need a little care in storage so they do not get crushed. Our guide to storing a flocked tree covers boxes, bags and keeping the white from yellowing.
Round goes to the Acacia Slim, the lighter tree to haul and stow.
Same warranty, one band apart
Both trees carry the same warranty, 5 years for the tree and 2 for the lights, and Amazon.com sells and ships both. The Wintry Pine sits in the $$$ band and the Acacia Slim in the $$ band.
Wintry Pine owners question its value, mostly when the tree looks thinner than the photos. Acacia Slim owners more often call theirs good value, and our flocked tree brands guide covers National Tree Company’s wider range.
Round goes to the Acacia Slim, for value.
The Wintry Pine’s weak spot is value for money. You pay a band more for decorations already attached, and some owners feel the tree underneath looks thin.
The Acacia Slim is narrow by design, so it will never fill a large room. Some owners also find its flocking heavier than they hoped.
Centerpiece or corner
For an open living room and a tree that looks dressed on day one, the Wintry Pine is the one to order. For a small room, a corner or a lower band, the Acacia Slim gives the same warranty and clear bulbs on half the floor.