Best Choice pre-lit or Yaheetech unlit, two flocked trees

Both trees stand 7.5 ft and weigh about 31 lb. The Best Choice arrives wired with 550 warm white LEDs, the Yaheetech arrives with bare branches and the widest base in our lineup, so the choice turns on how you want to light your tree.

Lights in the box with Best Choice, lights of your choosing with Yaheetech

These two 7.5 ft flocked trees match closely on height and weight. The split is the wiring, since one arrives with 550 warm white LEDs threaded through its branches and the other arrives bare, waiting for whatever lights you hang.

Pick the Best Choice Products 7.5 ft if you want to plug in and decorate on the evening it arrives. Pick the Yaheetech unlit tree if you already own good strings, want colored or smart lights, or dread a dead section you cannot swap out.

Both sit on our best flocked Christmas tree shortlist, the Best Choice as pick 1 and the Yaheetech as pick 2. The Yaheetech also meets a budget pre-lit rival in Hykolity or Yaheetech, and the Best Choice faces a decorated tree in Best Choice or Wintry Pine.

Best Choice and Yaheetech side by side

Every figure comes from the two Amazon listings and the brands’ own descriptions. Where a listing leaves a field blank, the table says so instead of guessing.

FeatureBest Choice Products 7.5 ftYaheetech 7.5 ft unlit
Height7.5 ft, 90 in with the stand7.5 ft, 89.8 in per the listing
Width at the base52 in55 in, the widest of our six
Branch tips1,3461,284, all bendable
Lights550, pre-strungNone
Light typeWarm white LEDWhatever you add
Modes3 (twinkle, slow fade, steady on)Set by your own strings
StandFoldable metal standCollapsible metal stand with floor caps
Weight30.5 lb31.7 lb
WarrantyNone listed, holiday return window onlyNone listed, holiday return window only
SellerBest Choice ProductsYaheetech
Price band$$$

550 warm white LEDs against bare branches

The Best Choice ships with 550 warm white LEDs and three settings, twinkle, slow fade and steady on. Warm white LEDs sit close to the yellow glow of old bulbs, stay cool to the touch and draw far less power than incandescent minis.

The Yaheetech ships with no lights at all. That is extra work, yet it lets you pick warm white, cool white, multicolor or a smart string, and change your mind the following December without buying a new tree.

Our pre-lit or unlit guide weighs that trade in more depth. Whatever strings you buy for the Yaheetech, look for a UL or ETL mark and check the maker’s limit on how many sets may be joined end to end.

Round goes to the Best Choice for convenience, to the Yaheetech for freedom.

52 in of dense branches or 55 in of spread

The Yaheetech is the widest tree in our lineup at 55 in across the base. The Best Choice is 3 in narrower yet carries 1,346 tips against 1,284, so it packs a few more tips into slightly less floor.

Owners of both trees praise a full shape once the tips are fluffed. Yaheetech owners also call it true to size, though some find gaps after fluffing, while Best Choice owners single out its heavy flocking.

Measure before you choose. A 55 in tree needs more than 4.5 ft of floor plus a path around it, and our tree size guide shows how to mark the spot out with tape before the box arrives.

Round goes to the Best Choice, for more tips on a smaller footprint.

Hinged sections, fluffing and the white mess

Both trees use hinged branches that drop into place as you stack the sections on the stand. Best Choice describes three steps (unfold the stand, stack the sections, fluff), and Yaheetech owners call assembly and storage easy.

Both shed flocking, mostly while you unbox and fluff. Some Yaheetech owners report branches that come loose during fluffing, and stringing your own lights adds a second round of handling that knocks off more white.

Lay an old sheet down and wear gloves. Our setup and fluffing guide and our guide to flocking that sheds cover the rest, from the order to fluff in to a vacuum on low with the beater bar off.

Round goes to the Best Choice, since lights already in place mean less handling.

When a section of lights goes dark

Best Choice owners like the tree, but a share of them report lights that stop working. On a pre-lit tree the dead section is wired into the branches, so the fix is a hunt for a loose bulb or a separate string laid over the top.

The Yaheetech has nothing wired in that can fail. If a string you bought dies, you unplug it, unwind it and hang another, and the tree itself carries on for as many years as its flocking holds up.

Either way, check every cord before the tree goes up and retire any string with worn insulation or loose sockets. Turn the lights off at bedtime and whenever you leave the house.

Round goes to the Yaheetech, for a tree with no wiring to wear out.

Stands, floors and the trip to the attic

Both stand on folding metal bases. The Yaheetech’s stand has caps on its feet to protect hard floors, while under the Best Choice you add felt pads or a tree mat yourself.

Weight is close, 30.5 lb against 31.7 lb, so either box is easier with two people on the attic stairs. Store it cool, dry and dark, in the original box or a tree bag, and the white stays white for longer.

With a dog or a toddler in the house, weight the stand or tie the trunk to a wall hook. Flocking is not food, so sweep up loose white before small hands or paws find it.

Round goes to the Yaheetech, for the stand caps.

The $ band plus lights, or the $$ band all in

The Yaheetech sits in the $ band and the Best Choice in the $$ band, and each is sold directly by its brand on Amazon. The gap shrinks once you price in lights, since a 7.5 ft tree takes several strings to look evenly lit.

The Best Choice is the most-reviewed flocked tree in our list, so its strengths and weak spots are well known. The Yaheetech has plenty of owner reviews behind it too, mostly about its shape and its easy setup.

A draw once the cost of lights is counted.

Neither listing promises a warranty, so a pre-lit tree whose strings fail after the return window leaves you with workarounds. That is the Best Choice’s weak spot, and owners mention it.

The Yaheetech’s drawback is labor. Wrapping lights through 1,284 flocked tips takes time and shakes loose more white, and the strings add to the bill.

Plug in tonight or light it your way

For a tree that glows the moment it stands, the Best Choice is the one we would order. For a tree that outlives any one set of lights, take the Yaheetech and string it yourself.

Questions and answers

More questions about the Best Choice and the Yaheetech

Is the Yaheetech 7.5 ft flocked tree pre-lit?

No. The 7.5 ft model in our lineup is the unlit version, so you add your own strings. Yaheetech also lists a pre-lit 6 ft flocked tree, so read the title before you order.

Which of the two trees is wider?

The Yaheetech, at 55 in across the base per its listing, the widest of our six. The Best Choice measures 52 in. Both are 7.5 ft tall.

Can I change the light modes on the Best Choice?

Yes. Its 550 warm white LEDs have three functions per the listing, twinkle, slow fade and steady on. The color stays warm white in every mode.

Which one sheds less flocking?

Owners of both report shedding, mostly during setup and fluffing. Stringing lights on the unlit Yaheetech means extra handling, so expect a little more white on the floor with it the first time.

Does either tree come with a warranty?

Neither listing names one. Both fall under Amazon’s holiday return window, so set the tree up and try every section of lights soon after it arrives.