A slim or a full flocked tree for your room
Both trees reach 7.5 ft, yet one covers twice the floor of the other. The National Tree Company Acacia Slim stands on a 26 in base, the Best Choice Products tree spreads to 52 in, and your room decides which shape fits.
Let the floor decide, not the photo
A full 7.5 ft tree and a pencil-slim one look alike in a listing photo with nothing around them. In your room, the full tree needs more than 4 ft of floor and the slim one about 2 ft, and that gap settles most cases before anything else.
Pick the National Tree Acacia Slim for a corner, a narrow hall, an apartment or a spot beside the TV. Pick the Best Choice Products 7.5 ft when the tree is the centerpiece of an open room and you want it dense with white.
Both trees appear in our flocked Christmas trees compared list, the Acacia Slim as pick 4 and the Best Choice as pick 1. The slim tree also meets a tabletop mini in tabletop or slim tree and its decorated sibling in Wintry Pine or Acacia Slim.
Acacia Slim and Best Choice side by side
The table uses the Amazon listings, National Tree Company’s details and the Best Choice brand description. Two heights appear for the Acacia Slim because its title and spec table differ.
| Feature | National Tree Acacia Slim | Best Choice Products 7.5 ft |
|---|---|---|
| Height | 7.5 ft (spec table 88.5 in) | 7.5 ft, 90 in including the stand |
| Width at the base | 26 in, pencil slim | 52 in |
| Branch tips | 641 | 1,346 |
| Lights | 350, pre-strung | 550, pre-strung |
| Light type | Clear incandescent, UL listed; the rest stay lit if one bulb goes out | Warm white LED |
| Modes | Steady, none listed | 3 (twinkle, slow fade, steady on) |
| Stand | Metal base | Foldable metal stand |
| Weight | 13.4 lb | 30.5 lb |
| Warranty | 5 years tree, 2 years lights | None listed |
| Seller | Amazon.com | Best Choice Products |
| Price band | $$ | $$ |
26 in against 52 in of floor
The Acacia Slim measures 26 in across its lowest branches, half the 52 in of the Best Choice. The chart below sets both against the other four trees in our lineup.
Add a walkway on top of the width. A 52 in tree beside a sofa or a doorway leaves little room to pass, while 26 in tucks into a corner or between two windows and still leaves the path clear.
Our size guide for flocked trees shows how to tape a footprint on the floor, and our guide to slim and tabletop trees covers rooms where every foot counts. Leave a little extra if a door swings nearby.
Round goes to the Acacia Slim in a small room, to the Best Choice in an open one.
641 tips or 1,346, and room for ornaments
The Best Choice carries more than twice the tips, 1,346 against 641. Owners call it full and praise its heavy flocking, and the pole disappears behind the branches.
Acacia Slim owners call it attractive with pretty flocking, and they like how it fits corners. Some find the flocking just right and others too heavy, and with fewer tips there is less space for a big ornament collection.
On a slim tree, smaller ornaments and a vertical ribbon suit the shape better than large baubles. On the full tree, you can layer big and small pieces at different depths.
Round goes to the Best Choice, for fullness and ornament space.
Clear bulbs that stay lit or LEDs with three modes
The Acacia Slim has 350 clear UL-listed incandescent bulbs, and National Tree Company says the rest stay lit if one bulb goes out. Clear bulbs throw a warm, slightly golden light that looks good on white flocking.
The Best Choice lights up with 550 warm white LEDs that can twinkle, slow fade or stay steady. LEDs stay cool and use far less power, though some Best Choice owners report sections that stop working.
Incandescent bulbs get warm, so keep any tree 3 ft from fireplaces, radiators and heat vents. Our tree lights guide compares the two types on glow, power and lifespan.
A draw, the LEDs for modes and power, the clear bulbs for their glow.
13.4 lb or 30.5 lb in the box
The Acacia Slim weighs 13.4 lb per its listing, less than half the 30.5 lb of the Best Choice. One adult can carry it up from a basement, while the Best Choice box is easier with a helper.
A lighter, narrower tree also asks for less storage space. Keep either in a cool, dry and dark spot, since heat and damp are what yellow and clump flocking over the years.
Round goes to the Acacia Slim, for weight and storage.
Thirty minutes of shaping or three steps
Both trees use hinged branches. National Tree Company suggests about 30 minutes to shape the Acacia Slim, and owners call it easy, while Best Choice lists three steps, unfold the stand, stack the sections and fluff.
The full tree has more than twice the tips to fluff, so expect it to take longer in practice and to shed more white on the floor. Put an old sheet down first and work from the bottom section up.
Round goes to the Acacia Slim, for fewer tips to shape.
A 5-year warranty or the most owner reviews
National Tree Company backs the Acacia Slim for 5 years on the tree and 2 on its bulbs, and Amazon.com handles the sale. The Best Choice listing names no warranty, and the brand sells it directly.
Both sit in the $$ band. Far more owners have reviewed the Best Choice than any other flocked tree here, so its failure points are well documented, while the Acacia Slim has far fewer reviews so far.
Split, the warranty to the Acacia Slim and the owner record to the Best Choice.
A slim tree is a trade. The Acacia Slim saves half the floor, but 641 tips will never look as lush as a full tree, and some owners find its flocking heavier than they wanted.
The Best Choice fills a room and can crowd a small one. Its listing also names no warranty, and some owners report light sections that fail.
Measure the corner, then choose
If your spot is narrow or the room is small, the Acacia Slim gives you a full 7.5 ft of height on half the floor. If the room is open and the tree is the centerpiece, the Best Choice is the fuller tree.