LED or incandescent lights on a flocked tree

White flocking shows off the color of every bulb. The same tree can look golden and soft under clear incandescent lights or crisp and modern under LEDs, and the type of bulb also changes the power draw, the heat and what happens when one fails.

The two kinds of mini light

An LED mini light uses far less electricity than an incandescent mini and runs cool to the touch. That makes LEDs the easy choice for a tree that stays lit for hours each evening.

An incandescent mini makes light by heating a thin filament, so it gets warm. Its glow is warm and slightly golden, and many people still prefer it on a snowy tree.

Which of the six trees use which

TreeLightsColorIf one bulb goes out
Best Choice Products 7.5 ft550 LEDWarm whiteNot stated
Hykolity 7.5 ft450 LEDWarm whiteNot stated
National Tree Acacia Slim350 incandescentClearThe rest stay lit (listing)
National Tree Wintry Pine650ClearThe rest stay lit (listing)
National Tree 3 ft mini50 incandescentClearNot stated
Yaheetech 7.5 ftNoneYour choiceDepends on your lights

The split is clean. Best Choice Products and Hykolity use warm white LEDs, while the National Tree Company trees stick with clear bulbs.

How each looks on white flocking

Clear incandescent bulbs throw a warm, slightly golden light that reads well against the white. The flocking takes on a soft glow, a bit like snow under a street lamp.

Warm white LEDs come close to that look, with a cleaner edge. Cool white LEDs look bluish, and on a flocked tree they can make the whole thing feel icy rather than cozy.

Multicolor lights tint the white around each bulb. Some people love the effect, and our guide on decorating a flocked tree shows which color schemes suit each kind of light.

How many lights a tree carries

Light count depends on the tree’s size and the maker’s style. The Wintry Pine carries 650 clear bulbs on 831 tips, while the Acacia Slim spreads 350 across its 641 tips on a much narrower frame.

The Best Choice tree shows how count grows with height. Its 4.5 ft version has 200 LEDs, the 7.5 ft has 550, and the 12 ft carries 1,700, according to the listing.

Power use and outlets

Because LED minis draw far less electricity, a pre-lit LED tree barely registers on a power bill. Clear incandescent strings use more, and they also warm the branches a little while they run.

Whichever type you choose, plug the tree straight into a wall outlet or a rated power strip. Do not overload one outlet by stacking the tree and the window lights on it together.

Light modes

Among our six trees, only the Best Choice Products listing mentions light modes, and its card sits under our top pick. Switching between twinkle, slow fade and steady on gives you a calm setting for dinner and a livelier one for a party.

The other pre-lit trees list their lights without modes. If you want effects on one of them, you would need to add a separate string with its own controller.

When a bulb or a section goes out

On many pre-lit trees, incandescent strings are wired so the rest stay lit when one bulb goes out. The listings say so for the National Tree Company Acacia Slim and the Wintry Pine.

A loose or missing bulb can still darken a section on older designs. Owner reports of sections that stop working come up for several trees in our list, LED and incandescent alike.

Some owners of the Wintry Pine mention light failures despite its premium price band. Our head-to-head of Best Choice and Hykolity weighs the two LED trees, including what owners say about their lights.

A warranty helps when a string fails. Both National Tree Company 7.5 ft trees list 2 years on the lights and 5 on the tree, while the other listings in our product data do not name one for the lights.

Pre-lit or your own lights

On a pre-lit tree, the maker has already chosen the bulb type for you. If you want a different color, or a set you can swap out when it fails, an unlit tree gives you that freedom.

Our guide to pre-lit or unlit flocked trees covers that choice in full. For a slim tree with clear bulbs already strung, the National Tree Company Acacia Slim carries 350 UL-listed incandescents on a 26 in base.

Using tree lights safely

  • Look for a UL or ETL mark from a testing laboratory, and use indoor lights indoors
  • Inspect every string before it goes up, and replace any with worn cords or loose bulb connections
  • Read the maker’s limit on how many strings you can connect end to end
  • Turn the lights off when you leave home or go to bed
  • Keep the tree 3 ft from heat sources such as a fireplace, a radiator or a heat vent
  • Run cords along walls, never under rugs or through doorways where they get pinched

Incandescent minis get warm, which is one more reason to keep them off paper decorations. Our flocked tree safety guide covers cords, outlets and homes with kids and pets.

Storing lights between seasons

Lights fail less when they are stored with care. Wind loose strings around a piece of cardboard, and keep pre-lit sections in a cool, dry place where the wires are not crushed.

Our guide to storing a flocked tree covers the tree bag and the spot that suits both flocking and wiring. When you are ready to choose, our guide on which flocked tree to buy compares all six, with the light details in the comparison table.

For warm white LEDs with modes

The Best Choice Products 7.5 ft tree has 550 warm white LEDs with twinkle, slow fade and steady on. Owners report that some sections can stop working over time, and the listing names no lights warranty.

Questions and answers

More questions about tree lights

Are LED or incandescent lights better on a flocked tree?

Both work. Clear incandescent bulbs give a warm, golden glow on white flocking, and warm white LEDs come close while using far less electricity and staying cool. Avoid cool white LEDs if you want a cozy look.

Do LED tree lights get hot?

No, LED mini lights run cool to the touch. Incandescent minis get warm, so keep them away from paper decorations and keep any tree 3 ft from heat sources.

What happens if one bulb goes out on a pre-lit tree?

On many incandescent strings the rest stay lit, and the listings say so for the National Tree Company 7.5 ft trees. A loose or missing bulb can still darken a section on older designs.

Which flocked trees have light modes?

Among the six trees we compare, only the Best Choice Products tree lists them. Its LEDs switch between twinkle, slow fade and steady on.

Should I leave tree lights on overnight?

No. NFPA and CPSC advise turning tree lights off before you leave home or go to bed, using lights with a UL or ETL mark, and replacing strings with worn cords.