Best Choice Products against Hykolity, two pre-lit flocked trees

Both trees stand 7.5 ft, both come with warm white LEDs and both have hinged branches. The Best Choice tree costs a band more, and this page shows what that extra band buys and where the cheaper Hykolity holds its own.

Best Choice for most homes, Hykolity to stay under $150

These are the two pre-lit LED trees in our six, and both stand 7.5 ft. The Best Choice Products 7.5 ft costs a band more and gives you heavier flocking, three light modes and a seller that is the brand itself.

The Hykolity 7.5 ft Flocked Prelit keeps you in the $ band with more tips and lighter flocking. Both appear in our best flocked Christmas trees list, as pick 1 and pick 3.

Choose the Best Choice tree for the main living room, where you want it to look snowed on from the sofa. Choose the Hykolity when the budget is firm, or for a second room where lighter flocking matters less.

The two pre-lit trees side by side

Figures come from the two Amazon listings. Where a listing contradicts itself, the table gives both numbers.

FeatureBest Choice Products 7.5 ftHykolity 7.5 ft
Height7.5 ft, 90 in including the stand7.5 ft
Width at the base52 in48 in
Branch tips1,3461,446 (spec table: 1,400)
FlockingSnow-flocked finish, called heavy by owners“Lightly flocked” per the listing
Lights550, pre-strung450, pre-strung
Light typeWarm white LEDWarm white LED
Modes3 (twinkle, slow fade, steady on)None named on the listing
StandFoldable metal standMetal stand
Weight30.5 lb38.1 lb
WarrantyNone in the details we collectedNone in the details we collected
SellerBest Choice ProductsA third-party seller
Other sizes4.5, 6, 9 and 12 ft6 ft
Price band$$$ (close to $150)

Round one, flocking and look

Best Choice describes green PVC needles with a snow-flocked finish, and owners praise both the look and how heavy the flocking is. From across a room, it reads as a white tree.

Hykolity’s own listing calls its tree “lightly flocked”, so more green shows between the white. If you picture a tree that looks dusted rather than snowed on, that may suit you fine.

Round goes to Best Choice, for the heavier flocking.

Round two, fullness and tips

On paper the Hykolity wins, with 1,446 tips against 1,346, though its spec table lists 1,400. It spreads those tips over a narrower base of 48 in, where the Best Choice reaches 52 in.

Owners call the Best Choice tree full, while some Hykolity owners say it looks smaller than they expected. Both depend on patient fluffing, which our tip count entry explains.

Bar chart of the number of branch tips on each of the six flocked Christmas trees
Branch tips from each listing. More tips on the same height means a fuller tree with fewer gaps, and usually more weight to carry.

Round goes to neither, a draw on fullness.

Round three, lights and modes

Both trees use warm white LEDs, which run cool and look close to the glow of incandescent bulbs. Best Choice strings 550 of them and Hykolity 450, a gap you will see on a tree of the same height.

Best Choice adds three modes, twinkle, slow fade and steady on, while we found no modes named for the Hykolity. Owners of both report light sections that stop working, and our LED or incandescent guide covers what to do then.

Round goes to Best Choice, for more lights and the modes.

Round four, setup and weight

Both trees use hinged branches, and owners of each call assembly easy. Best Choice lists three steps, unfolding the stand, stacking the sections and fluffing.

The weights differ more than you might expect. On the listings, Best Choice comes in at 30.5 lb against 38.1 lb for the Hykolity, the heaviest tree in our lineup, which counts when you haul the box from storage.

Round goes to Best Choice, the lighter tree to carry.

Round five, price and seller

The Hykolity sits in the $ band, close to the $150 line, and the Best Choice tree in the $$ band. If staying under $150 decides it, only the Hykolity does that.

Best Choice ships and sells its own tree, while the Hykolity comes from a third-party seller. Both listings showed free returns through the holiday return window, and our guide to flocked tree brands explains why the seller line matters.

Size options differ as well. Best Choice sells the design at 4.5, 6, 9 and 12 ft besides 7.5 ft, while Hykolity offers a 6 ft version, so the Best Choice line covers more ceilings.

Round goes to Hykolity, on price.

Round six, shedding and storage

Owners of both trees mention flocking coming off, mostly while they unbox and fluff. Heavier flocking gives the Best Choice tree more to lose, while the lighter Hykolity coat still draws mixed reports.

The fix is the same for both trees. Lay an old sheet under the stand, wear gloves while you shape the branches and run a vacuum on low with no beater bar afterward.

Storage matters as much as setup, since sun and warmth slowly turn white flocking yellow. Pack either tree in a tree bag or its box, and keep it somewhere cool, dry and dark rather than in a hot attic.

Round goes to neither, both trees shed and store the same way.

Where each tree stands in the lineup

If you are torn between lit and unlit, our Best Choice against Yaheetech page sets the top pick against an unlit tree. For two budget trees side by side, see Hykolity against Yaheetech.

Either tree needs the same care in your home. Leave a 3 ft gap to any heat source, and switch the lights off overnight and whenever nobody is home.

The Best Choice tree does not escape the budget problems. Owners of both trees report shedding and light sections that stop working, so the extra band buys heavier flocking and a known seller, not a tree that never fails.

The Hykolity listing is the thinner of the two on detail. It names no light modes and gives two different tip counts.

Our call between the two

The Best Choice Products 7.5 ft is our pick for most homes, with heavier flocking, 550 LEDs with three modes and the brand as seller. Choose the Hykolity if staying under $150 matters more than a whiter look.

Questions and answers

More questions about Best Choice and Hykolity

Is the Best Choice or the Hykolity flocked tree better?

For most homes we pick the Best Choice Products 7.5 ft: heavier flocking, 550 warm white LEDs with three modes and the brand as seller. The Hykolity wins on price, sitting in the under-$150 band.

Which tree has more branch tips?

The Hykolity lists 1,446 tips, though its spec table says 1,400. The Best Choice tree lists 1,346, on a wider 52 in base against the Hykolity’s 48 in.

Do both trees have light modes?

The Best Choice tree lists three: twinkle, slow fade and steady on. We found no light modes named on the Hykolity listing.

Which tree is heavier?

The Hykolity is heavier. Its listing gives 38.1 lb, the most of any tree in our lineup, against 30.5 lb for the Best Choice tree.

Do both trees shed flocking?

Yes. Owners of both mention flocking coming off, mostly during setup and fluffing. Every flocked tree sheds some, and gloves plus an old sheet under the tree help.