Flocked or green, which Christmas tree suits your home
A snowy tree looks like a winter postcard in the box photo. Living with one is a little different from living with a plain green tree, so this guide sets the two side by side on looks, mess, lights and the years ahead.
What flocking is
Flocking is the white “snow” bonded to the needles of an artificial tree. It is typically fine fibers, often cellulose, held on by an adhesive, sometimes with a flame-retardant mixed in.
Under the flocking sits an ordinary artificial tree, usually green PVC tips with a few molded PE tips on some models. Strip the white away and you would have a plain green tree with the same frame and lights.
That makes the choice mostly about the coat. Height, width and branch count still matter in the same way, and our guide to what size tree fits your room covers them for both kinds.
How the two look in a room
A green tree reads as a dark shape against the wall, and colored ornaments pop out of it. A flocked tree is lighter and softer, and it looks like a tree brought in from a snowy yard.
The amount of white varies a lot. The Best Choice Products tree carries heavy flocking that owners praise for the look, while the Hykolity is sold as “lightly flocked,” with more green showing through.
White branches also change your decorations. Silver, gold and deep reds stand out against snow, while pale pastels can disappear. Six color schemes are laid out in how to decorate a flocked tree.
Heavy or light flocking
Owners of the National Tree Company Acacia Slim split on this. Some call the flocking just right and others find it too heavy, which shows that the amount of snow is partly taste.
Photos on a listing are often taken under bright lights that make flocking look whiter. Read the owner comments about how snowy the tree looks at home before you decide how much white you want.
Fullness counts on both kinds
Flocking makes thin branches look fuller, because the white fills the gaps your eye would see on a green tree. Tip count still decides the base fullness, and the chart shows how far the six flocked trees we compare spread.
For a plain green contrast, the Puleo International 7.5 ft Aspen Fir, a tree we dropped from the shortlist because it is not flocked, lists 1,319 tips. That puts it in the same range as the fuller flocked trees here.
The mess, and why green trees win here
Every flocked tree sheds some white, mostly while you unbox, set up and fluff it. A plain green tree has no coat to lose, so the first evening is far tidier.
Owners of nearly every tree in our list mention flocking on the floor during setup. Our guide to whether a flocked tree sheds explains why it happens and gives seven ways to keep most of it off the rug.
Flocking is not food. If a pet or a toddler chews the branches and swallows a lot of it, call a vet or a doctor, and keep a flocked tree out of reach of chewers.
Lights look different on white
Clear incandescent bulbs give a warm, slightly golden glow that reads well against white flocking. Warm white LEDs look closer to that glow, while cool white LEDs look bluish and can make a snowy tree feel colder.
The National Tree Company trees in our list use clear bulbs, and the Wintry Pine carries 650 of them with pine cones and red berries already attached. Our Wintry Pine review covers that tree, including owners who question its value.
A green tree takes multicolor lights more easily, since the dark branches frame each bulb. On a flocked tree, colored lights tint the white around them, which some people like and others find busy.
Care over the years
Heat, sunlight and long storage in a hot attic can yellow white flocking over the years. Moisture can make it clump, so a damp basement is no better than a hot attic.
A green tree forgives poor storage more easily. Our guide to storing a flocked tree covers the cool, dry, dark spot and the tree bag that keep the white looking fresh.
Fire resistance is the same question for both
The CPSC advises that an artificial tree should be labeled “fire resistant,” flocked or not. That label means the tree resists catching fire, not that it cannot burn.
Best Choice Products describes its branches as flame-retardant PVC, and National Tree Company calls its needles fire-resistant. Either way, keep any tree 3 ft from heat sources and turn the lights off at bedtime.
Side by side
| Flocked | Plain green | |
|---|---|---|
| Look | Soft, snowy, light against the wall | Dark, classic, ornaments stand out |
| Setup | Some flocking falls off; gloves and a sheet help | No white to shed |
| Lights that suit | Clear or warm white | Any, including multicolor |
| Storage | Cool, dry and dark to keep it white | More forgiving |
| Pets and toddlers | Flocking is not food; watch for chewing | Still keep needles out of mouths |
Which one should you pick
- Choose flocked if you want a winter look with less decorating, and you can live with some sweeping during setup
- Choose lightly flocked if you want a hint of snow with less mess, as on the Hykolity
- Choose green if you love multicolor lights, have a chewing pet, or store the tree in a hot attic
If you go snowy, the brand matters for lights and warranty. Our look at who makes the best flocked tree compares the makers, and the Best Choice Products 7.5 ft tree is our top pick for most homes.
All six are flocked Christmas trees compared on one page. The which kind of tree section sorts them by type, and all six trees have their own cards.
For a snowy tree that comes decorated
The National Tree Company Wintry Pine arrives flocked, with pine cones, red berry clusters and 650 clear lights. It sits in the top price band, and some owners find it thinner than pictured.