A plain flocked tree or one that comes decorated
The Best Choice is a full, snowy pine with 550 warm white LEDs and nothing else on it. The National Tree Company Wintry Pine ships with pine cones, red berry clusters and 650 clear bulbs already in place, one price band higher.
A blank canvas or a tree that is half dressed
The Best Choice gives you a dense white tree and leaves every ornament choice to you. The Wintry Pine comes with pine cones and red berry clusters fixed to its branches, so it looks finished with a topper and a ribbon or two.
Choose the Best Choice Products 7.5 ft if you like to change themes, want LED light modes, or would rather spend less. Choose the National Tree Wintry Pine if you want a woodland look without collecting decorations, and a stated warranty matters to you.
On our flocked Christmas tree comparison, the Best Choice is pick 1 and the Wintry Pine pick 6. The Best Choice also meets an unlit tree in pre-lit or unlit, and the Wintry Pine faces its slim sibling in Wintry Pine or Acacia Slim.
The plain tree and the decorated tree side by side
Figures come from the Amazon listings, the Best Choice brand description and National Tree Company’s product details. Neither tree has been in our hands, so read them as maker claims.
| Feature | Best Choice Products 7.5 ft | National Tree Wintry Pine |
|---|---|---|
| Height | 7.5 ft (90 in, stand included) | 7.5 ft (90 in) |
| Width at the base | 52 in | 47 in |
| Branch tips | 1,346 | 831 |
| Lights | 550, pre-strung | 650, pre-strung |
| Light type | Warm white LED | Clear incandescent; the rest stay lit if one bulb goes out |
| Modes | 3 (twinkle, slow fade, steady on) | Steady, no modes listed |
| Stand | Foldable metal stand | Metal base |
| Weight | 30.5 lb | 33.2 lb |
| Warranty | None listed | 5 years tree, 2 years lights |
| Seller | Best Choice Products | Amazon.com |
| Price band | $$ | $$$ |
1,346 tips against 831
The Best Choice carries 1,346 tips on a 52 in base. The Wintry Pine has 831 tips on a 47 in base, a medium profile that leaves more space between the branches by design.
Owners notice the difference. Best Choice owners call the tree full and praise its heavy flocking, while Wintry Pine owners are split, and some find it thinner than the photos suggest.
A fuller tree hides the pole and the wiring better, and a more open one shows off each ornament. Our guide to decorating a flocked tree covers how to fill gaps with picks and ribbon if you go with the open shape.
Round goes to the Best Choice, for fullness.
Pine cones and berries you cannot take off
The Wintry Pine’s cones and red berry clusters are part of the tree. They give a rustic, wintry look from the first evening, and they set your palette, since red and natural brown will be on display whatever else you hang.
The Best Choice is plain white over green, which suits silver and blue one year and gold or pink the next. You do the work and buy the ornaments, but no theme is ruled out.
Red berries on white flocking is the classic snowy-woods palette, and plaid ribbon or brass bells sit well with it. Pale blue and silver can fight the red, so plan around what is already on the branches.
Round goes to the Wintry Pine if you want it done, to the Best Choice if you like to change it.
Warm white LEDs or 650 clear bulbs
The Best Choice uses 550 warm white LEDs with three modes, twinkle, slow fade and steady on. LEDs run cool and use far less electricity than incandescent minis, which counts if the tree stays lit for hours each evening.
The Wintry Pine has 650 clear incandescent bulbs, wired so the rest stay lit when one goes out. Clear bulbs give a slightly golden glow that reads well on white flocking, and owners call them bright.
Owners of both report some light failures. Our LED or incandescent lights guide compares the two kinds of bulb, and whichever you pick, switch the tree off at bedtime and keep it 3 ft from any heat source.
A draw, decided by the glow you prefer.
Three steps against 45 to 60 minutes
Both trees have hinged branches. Best Choice describes a three-step assembly (unfold the stand, stack the sections, fluff), and owners call it easy.
National Tree Company says to set aside 45 to 60 minutes to shape the Wintry Pine. Owners still call assembly easy, but the cones and berries mean you fluff around them with a little more care.
Both shed some flocking while you work, so lay down a sheet first. Our setup and fluffing guide walks through the order, bottom section first, and gloves keep the white off your sleeves.
Round goes to the Best Choice, for the shorter setup.
A stated warranty against a lower band
The Wintry Pine carries a 5-year warranty on the tree and 2 years on the lights, and Amazon.com sells and ships it. The Best Choice listing names no warranty, only the holiday return window, and the brand sells it directly.
Price is where the Wintry Pine loses ground. It sits in the $$$ band, one band above the Best Choice in the $$ band, and owners question whether a tree with 831 tips justifies that.
Add the ornaments you would buy to fill a plain tree and the gap narrows. It does not close for most homes, which already own a box of decorations.
Round goes to the Best Choice on value, to the Wintry Pine on warranty.
The Wintry Pine’s weak point is value. Owners love the look, but some find it thinner than pictured, and that hurts more on a tree in the $$$ band.
The Best Choice has a quieter risk, because its listing names no warranty. If a light section fails after the return window, you lay a fresh string over the top.
Decorate it yourself or start decorated
For most rooms the Best Choice is the tree we would buy, full and bright and ready for any theme. If you want a woodland look with no ornament shopping and a 5-year warranty, the Wintry Pine delivers it at a higher band.